"LOVE THIS PLACE!!! My husband and I have been eating at The Old Mill since we were kids. We now live in Louisville KY and still try to go as often as possible. Pretty sure its probably one of the only places you can still get all you can eat crab legs. AND they are BETTER than most places where you have to pay by weight!!! We were in Evansville tonight and they stayed open for us during a blizzard even though we were the only people there....And they kept the crab legs coming hot and fresh! GREAT FOOD and AMAZING PEOPLE!"

"The food was good. We went for crab legs and seafood and had to wait often for them to come out. However the staff was amazing and the building historic so I enjoyed it."

"Excellent home style buffet with crab legs and prime rib. Don't expect Golden Corral this is a private family style restaurant with lots of homemade dishes in a rustic lodge atmosphere. Restrooms could use some updating."

" Love their all u can crab and more Sat night Great food."